Sorry I didn’t take a before pic but this is after using the private cream for 3 months . I basically spent my 20s having children and every time during my pregnancy this area got extremely dark almost black since I’m naturally brown . After my first 2 months I didn’t get a refill so I’m surprised that even without being 3 consecutive months it’s gotten so much more even toned . I’ll forever get my refills I thought nothing would work Musley changed that.